Difference between revisions of "User:Firespeaker/Comparison"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Firespeaker (talk | contribs) |
Firespeaker (talk | contribs) |
||
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 25: | Line 25: | ||
== The European perspective == |
== The European perspective == |
||
This takes into account a lot of stuff, but linguistic parameters are fallen back on when geographic, social, etc. things don't work well. |
|||
* Romance: |
* Romance: |
||
** Kyrgyz:Galician |
** Kyrgyz:Galician |
||
** Kazakh:European Portuguese |
** Kazakh:European Portuguese |
||
** Tatar: |
** Tatar:Brazilian Portuguese |
||
** Uzbek:American Spanishes |
** Uzbek:American Spanishes |
||
** Uyghur:Castillian |
** Uyghur:Castillian |
||
| Line 38: | Line 40: | ||
* Germanic: |
* Germanic: |
||
** |
** Chuvash:English |
||
** Tatar:Swedish |
** Tatar:Swedish |
||
** Bashqort:Danish |
** Bashqort:Danish |
||
** Uyghur:Dutch |
** Uyghur:Dutch |
||
** Uzbek:Low German |
** Uzbek:Low German |
||
** |
** Turkmen:German |
||
** Turkish:Yiddish |
|||
*** Relatively conservative phonologically, but with a handful of wide-spread specific changes, and a certain amount of leveling |
|||
*** Less conservative semantics |
|||
*** Lots of Semitic vocab |
|||
*** Quite a few dialects |
|||
*** Somewhat boring linguistically (compared to relatives) |
|||
** There is no Icelandic |
|||
Latest revision as of 18:24, 12 July 2013
The good and the bad[edit]
| language | affinity | TR vowel harmony | rounding harmony | weird orthographical tricks | Cyrillic? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kazakh | Turkic | yes | some | yes | awesome |
| Kyrgyz | Turkic | no | pervasive | minimal | meh |
| Tatar | Turkic | no | none | some | meh |
| Bashkir | Turkic | no | yes | minimal | awesome |
| Khalkha | Mongolic | yes | pervasive | tons | bleh |
| Kalmyk | Mongolic | no | ? | ? | awesome |
The European perspective[edit]
This takes into account a lot of stuff, but linguistic parameters are fallen back on when geographic, social, etc. things don't work well.
- Romance:
- Kyrgyz:Galician
- Kazakh:European Portuguese
- Tatar:Brazilian Portuguese
- Uzbek:American Spanishes
- Uyghur:Castillian
- Chuvash:Romanian
- Tuvan:Romanche
- Turkish:French
- Turkmen:Catalan
- Azeri:Occitan
- Germanic:
- Chuvash:English
- Tatar:Swedish
- Bashqort:Danish
- Uyghur:Dutch
- Uzbek:Low German
- Turkmen:German
- Turkish:Yiddish
- Relatively conservative phonologically, but with a handful of wide-spread specific changes, and a certain amount of leveling
- Less conservative semantics
- Lots of Semitic vocab
- Quite a few dialects
- Somewhat boring linguistically (compared to relatives)
- There is no Icelandic
