Morphology of Khalkha/АА vowel harmony issue - Revision history

Firespeaker: /* The main rule */

2012-12-22T23:30:25Z

The main rule

Firespeaker: /* The main rule */

2012-12-22T10:04:08Z

The main rule

Firespeaker: /* Some assumptions */

2012-12-22T08:53:56Z

Some assumptions

Firespeaker: /* Some assumptions */

2012-12-22T08:52:34Z

Some assumptions

Firespeaker: /* Some assumptions */

2012-12-22T08:51:08Z

Some assumptions

Firespeaker: /* Other potentially relevant rules */

2012-12-22T08:36:21Z

Other potentially relevant rules

Firespeaker: /* Some defaults */

2012-12-22T08:34:31Z

Some defaults

Firespeaker at 08:33, 22 December 2012

2012-12-22T08:33:41Z

Firespeaker: /* Some defaults */

2012-12-22T08:32:09Z

Some defaults

Firespeaker: moved Morphology of Khalkha/АА vowel harmony to Morphology of Khalkha/АА vowel harmony issue

2012-12-22T08:30:48Z

moved Morphology of Khalkha/АА vowel harmony to Morphology of Khalkha/АА vowel harmony issue

@@ Line 11: / Line 11: @@
 == The main rule ==
-In this form, the rule "works" for the example [[#Expected behaviour|above]].  See [[#Variants of the crucial line|below]] for variants that do and don't work.
+In this form, the rule "works" for the example [[#Expected behaviour|above]].  See [[#Variants of the crucial line|below]] for variants that do and don't work, as well as [[#Some assumptions|some assumptions]] and [[#Other potentially relevant rules|other potentially relevant rules]].
 <pre>
 "{A} vowel harmony for second {А} in {А}{А}"

@@ Line 11: / Line 11: @@
 == The main rule ==
+In this form, the rule "works" for the example [[#Expected behaviour|above]].  See [[#Variants of the crucial line|below]] for variants that do and don't work.
 <pre>
 "{A} vowel harmony for second {А} in {А}{А}"

@@ Line 44: / Line 44: @@
 E.g. in context {У}:ү г:г {I}: {А}:ө г:г _
 </pre>
-: In these cases, the <code>{А}</code> should harmonise to the previous {А} (which surfaces as a vowel).  But what's weirder is that the context does not require that an <code>{А}:</code> precedes _ .....
+: In these cases, the <code>{А}</code> should harmonise to the previous <code>{А}</code> (which surfaces as a vowel).  But what's weirder is that the context does not require that an <code>{А}:</code> precede <code>_</code> .
 == Other potentially relevant rules ==

@@ Line 44: / Line 44: @@
 E.g. in context {У}:ү г:г {I}: {А}:ө г:г _
 </pre>
+: In these cases, the <code>{А}</code> should harmonise to the previous {А} (which surfaces as a vowel).  But what's weirder is that the context does not require that an <code>{А}:</code> precedes _ .....
 == Other potentially relevant rules ==

@@ Line 36: / Line 36: @@
 == Some assumptions ==
 * By using <code>/[ :0 | :%  ]</code>, I should have any number of <code>%>:0</code> interspersed in all locations in <code>[ :NonVow* :NonVow ]</code>, though this doesn't seem to be the case, since <code>[ :NonVow* %>: :NonVow ]</code> behaves differently from <code>[ :NonVow* :NonVow ]/[ :0 ]</code>.  It doesn't seem to matter whether the things after <code>/</code> have <code>*</code> after them or not.
+* The point of the rule is to change the second <code>{А}</code> (when there are two <code>{А}</code>s in a row) to a certain vowel based on the last vowel seen before the series of <code>{А}</code>s.  That previous vowel, by the language's phonotactics, must occur with at least one non-vowel (up to 4 or so) intervening between the previous vowel and the <code>{А}</code>.  However, when I make the rule as <code>%{А%}:Vy <=> :Vx [ :NonVow* :NonVow ]/[ [ :0 - %{А%}: ] | :%  ] %{А%}:Vow _ ;</code>, I get conflicts like/including the following:
+<pre>
+There is a <=-rule conflict between "{A} vowel harmony for second {А} in {А}{А} SUBCASE: Vx=ү Vy=э" and "{A} vowel harmony for second {А} in {А}{А} SUBCASE: Vx=э Vy=э".
+E.g. in context {У}:ү г:г {I}: {А}:э г:г _
+There is a <=-rule conflict between "{A} vowel harmony for second {А} in {А}{А} SUBCASE: Vx=ү Vy=э" and "{A} vowel harmony for second {А} in {А}{А} SUBCASE: Vx=ө Vy=ө".
+E.g. in context {У}:ү г:г {I}: {А}:ө г:г _
+</pre>
 == Other potentially relevant rules ==

@@ Line 54: / Line 54: @@
          except
              _ %{А%}: ;  ! if {A}{A}, only do second {A}
-             ь:/:0 _ ;
          where Vx in ( е ё и )
                Vy in ( э о э )
@@ Line 64: / Line 63: @@
 </pre>
 == Some defaults ==
 <pre>

← Older revision		Revision as of 08:34, 22 December 2012
Line 76:		Line 76:

	Y = е я ё ;		Y = е я ё ;


	</pre>		</pre>

@@ Line 16: / Line 16: @@
          except
              _ %{А%}: ;  ! if {A}{A}, only do second {A}
-             ь:/:0 _ ;
          where Vx in ( ү э ө о )
                Vy in ( э э ө о )
@@ Line 75: / Line 74: @@
 NonVow = Б В Г Д Е Ж З Й К Л М Н П Р С Т Ф Х Ц Ч Ш Ь Ъ Я
          б в г д е ж з й к л м н п р с т ф х ц ч ш ь ъ я ;
+Y = е я ё ;
 </pre>

@@ Line 72: / Line 72: @@
  %{А%}:а %{I%}:ы %{У%}:у                 ! Vowels
  ° %% %, %. %- %>:0 %
+NonVow = Б В Г Д Е Ж З Й К Л М Н П Р С Т Ф Х Ц Ч Ш Ь Ъ Я
+         б в г д е ж з й к л м н п р с т ф х ц ч ш ь ъ я ;
 </pre>

← Older revision	Revision as of 08:30, 22 December 2012
(No difference)